MIS 411/511 Required Texts
Appendix A : Electronic Class Discussions
Class discussions are key to helping you learn about complex ideas where there
are several different relevant perspectives. Many students enjoy discussions,
but some are more timid. Therefore, there will be two ways to participate in class
discussions. In addition to the discussions which take place with the lectures,
small group discussions on a computer conferencing system will be devoted to
this class (mis411.511).
Electronic Etiquette:
There are no hard and fast rules regarding computer etiquette, so you will need
new ways to convey "feeling" or to recognize signals from others in a conference.
Some examples include:
- EMPHASIS: You can format BIG changes in meaning by capitalizing a
word, oryou can add *emphasis* with highlighting marks, or you can
comment parenthetically (to clarify meaning), or you can misspell with intent
to provide sooooo much feeling.
- HUMOR: It is useful to provide a light touch (laugh) at times. You can
also illustrate your frustration (e.g., !!!!! I did it again!!!), or that you are
thinking (e.g., Hm... that seems strange). What is important is that you let
readers know when you are kidding or joking around. A sideways smile :-) is
an easy way to convey humor.
Edit your posts before you post them to the conference for factual correctness,
logic, and grammar. Posts making corrections to your earlier posts are
bothersome. Do not criticize individuals -- criticize their logic, data, etc.
Grading the Posts:
I will be reading the posts every day or two and responding to them. This means
you should also be reading our conference a few times a week. I expect that 1 to
2 posts a week would be a good average to maintain. To make an informed post,
you should have read the assignments for the topic to which we are referring.
Your class discussion grade will depend upon the entire corpus of your posts.
Iwill be grading the posts for:
- Knowledge (Have you read the assigned materials?)
- Relevance (Is your contribution helpful to the discussion?)
- Logic (Do you make good points and defend them ably?)
- Etiquette (Are you polite?)
- Insight (Do you look at the problem in a novel, helpfulway?)
Making a Post (or "I don't have anything to say!"):
There are lots of ways that you can contribute to the class discussion. They do not all
require having some fabulous insight or world-shattering theory. Here are some
suggestions of what might be a useful contribution.
- Bringing Things Up
- offering information
- offering an opinion (someone else's or your own)
- giving examples (or counter-examples)
- providing evidence (for or against)
- pursuing and analyzing an argument, example, suggestion
- Clearing Things Up
- revealing confusion
- clarifying
- indicating alternatives
- testing for agreement
- identifying areas of disagreement
- suggesting an integrative agreement or compromise
- Social & Emotional Work
- relieving group tension
- offering encouragement
- expressing feelings
- agreeing with another person's comment, question, feeling
- Directing Traffic
- bringing up a new topic
- setting standards
- pointing out prejudiced, narrow-minded, or simplistic arguments
- gatekeeping (helping someone else in and out of the discussion)
- summarizing
- Asking For Things
- asking for clarification
- raising new questions
- seeking information from other participants
- seeking opinions from other other participants
Back to the MIS 411 Menu