HISTORY 477/577
Comparative History of World Revolutions
Fall 2005
History 477/577 Dr.
David Ortiz Jr.
Lectures: T-TH
Office Hours: T&Th
-
Revolutions, defined as
comparatively brief, sudden socio-political changes, have been an axiom of the
modern historical development of nations.
We will have occasion to tinker with this definition throughout the
semester. In the course of that
tinkering, this course studies the nature of revolutions in comparative
historical perspective beginning with the French Revolution of 1789 – the standard
by which revolutionary change has occurred since the eighteenth century. We will also tour the globe looking at
revolutionary effervescence in
(Hist 477 & 577)
Jack
A. Goldstone, Revolutions: Theoretical,
Comparative, and Historical Studies
Ji-Li
Jiang, Red Scarf Girl – A Memoir of the Cultural
Revolution
Roy
Rowan, Chasing the Dragon – A Veteran Journalist’s
Firsthand Account of the 1949 Chinese Revolution
David
S. Mason, Revolutionary
Jeff
Goodwin, No Other Way Out – States and
Revolutionary Movements 1945-1991
(Hist 577 only)
Theda Skocpol, Social Revolutions in the Modern
World
Noel
Parker, Revolutions and History
James
DeFronzo, Revolutions and Revolutionary Movements
John
Foran, edit., Theorizing Revolutions
Course Note: This course is a standard
History course, which means there is a great deal of reading and writing. Therefore,
if your schedule is too heavy, if you work too many hours, if for any reason
you cannot commit to the level of work required, you should seriously consider
dropping this course. Do not worry, I
teach this course periodically so you may take it later when it better fits
your schedule.
Weekly agenda: The course outline below is simply a guide to help students organize their reading. In general, I will try to reserve 20-30 minutes at the end of each class for questions and discussion. Please do all of the course reading by Tuesday so that you are prepared on Tuesdays and Thursdays to answer questions and discuss the texts. I may deviate from this outline from time to time.
Week
1: Introduction
(33)
Aug.
23, 25 Reading:
Goldstone, Intro; Mason, Intro & Ch. 1
Week
2: *Theory
and Revolution (69)
Aug.
30, Sept. 1 Reading:
Goldstone, Chs. 1 & 5; Mason,
Week
3: *Industrialization
and its Discontents (73)
Sept.
6, 8 Reading:
Mason, Chs. 3 through 6; Rowan,
Week
4: *The
‘Capitalist’ War (85)
Week
5: The
Russian Revolution in Theory and Practice (83)
Sept.
20, 22 Reading:
Goldstone, Chs. 2 & 6; Mason,
Sept.
27, 29 Reading:
Goldstone, Chs. 3 & 7; Rowan, Chs.
7 & 8
Week
7: *
Oct. 4, 6 Reading: Mason, Chs. 10 through 12; Rowan, Chs. 9 through 11
Week
8: Witnessing
Mao’s Revolution (68)
Oct.
11, 13 Reading:
Rowan, Chs. 12 through Epilogue
Assignment
#2 Due
Week
9: *Revolutions
Compared (101)
Oct.
18, 20 Reading:
Goodwin, Chs. 1 & 2; Jiang,
pp. 1-37
Week
10: *Fruits
of Decolonization? Southeast Asian Revolutions (99)
Oct.
25, 27 Reading:
Goodwin, Chs. 3 & 4; Jiang,
pp. 38-71
Week
11: *Populist
Revolutions? Twentieth-Century
Nov.
1, 3 Reading:
Goodwin, Chs. 5 & 6; Jiang,
pp. 72-99
Week
12: *‘Guerrilla’
and ‘Ethnic’ Models – L.Am., S.Africa, Pal., & Afghan.
(104)
Nov.
8, 10 Reading:
Goldstone, pp. 107-154, 284-324; Jiang, pp. 100-117
Week
13: *Revolution
Returns to
Nov.
15, 17 Reading:
Week
14: A
‘Cultural’ Revolution? (99)
Nov.
22, 24 Reading:
Jiang, pp. 118-217
Thursday,
Thanksgiving
Week
15: *Student
Revolts in
Nov.
29, Dec. 1 Reading:
Goldstone, 271-283; Jiang, pp. 218-272
Week
16: *Are
Revolutions Outdated? (76)
Dec.
6 Reading:
Assignment #3 Due
Attendance – I do not take attendance, but the pace of the
course is such that students who do not attend regularly or who come to
class unprepared will have a very difficult time passing this course. My lectures will be interspersed with
frequent, open classroom discussion of the readings and issues raised by the
readings. Students are expected to
meet assignment deadlines, prepare their reading assignments conscientiously,
and participate intelligently in classroom discussions.
Etiquette –
Students are required to treat each other and the instructor with respect. There are new codes of conduct regarding
classroom behavior (see ABOR 5-308 & 5-401) that must be observed in
order to facilitate a learning environment.
Disruptive behavior (cell phone use, refusing to be seated, talking
during lectures, sleeping, eating, newspaper reading, entering late or leaving
early without authorization, etc.) is behavior that obstructs teaching or
learning in my classroom. I take
disruptions of this sort very personally and will take immediate action to
curtail such behavior in this classroom.
Grading – The student’s final grade
for the course will be based on three assignments:
Assignment #1 Weekly – 35% of your grade. These may
be journal entries or response/thought pieces.
Assignments are to be typed, 2-3 pages each. There are twelve of these assignments
throughout the semester, marked by an asterisk* in the course outline. I will drop the lowest two graded
assignments. No make-ups are allowed. The average of all weekly assignment grades
will be computed to arrive at an overall grade.
Assignment #2 Project – 35% of your grade. This may be a topical/thesis-based paper, a
critical book review, a biography, or a document analysis. This assignment is a minimum of 8-10 pages
and is due on the
Assignment#3 Final – 30% of your grade. This will be a typed take-home exam. This assignment is due on
History
577 – There
is a graduate section of this class.
Graduate students will have a more extensive reading list, in addition
to the readings assigned for the undergraduate course. That reading list will be negotiated between
the instructor and the graduate students in such a way as to enhance their
current course of individual study.
Graduate students are expected to attend the undergraduate lectures
regularly and meet with the instructor on a group basis, bi-weekly, in order to
discuss their additional readings.
Graduate students will write response papers (3 page maximum) on their extra-class
readings, a historiography paper (10-12 pages, the topic of which will be
determined in concert with the instructor), and an annotated bibliography. Graduate student grading will be as
follows; Meetings/Engagement 20%, Response papers 20%, Historiography Paper
25%, Annotated Bibliography 35%.
IMPORTANT ADDENDA: Students with special
circumstances that could impair their ability to meet course requirements must
make their situations known to the instructor prior to exam and
assignment due dates. This course may
present very controversial subject matter (sexuality, ethnicity, gender,
etc.). Censorship is not consistent with
the goals of this class or my own beliefs about a university education.
Students unwilling to engage with readings, lectures, film, video, music or
discussions of such issues, for whatever reasons, should drop this course. Remaining
in this course constitutes student acceptance of all of the above class norms.